If you’ve ever switched blood sugar meters and thought, “Wait, why are my numbers suddenly higher (or lower)?” — you are not alone. Many of us (managing gestational diabetes) run into this frustration, and it can feel stressful when you’re doing everything right but the numbers don’t seem to match up.
The truth is, glucose meter accuracy can vary — sometimes by more than you’d expect. Here’s why that happens, what it means for you, and what you can do to make sure your numbers give you clarity (not confusion).
There are a few reasons why switching to a new meter can suddenly change your results:
Allowed variance: Most home glucose meters are considered accurate if they’re within about 15% of a lab result. That means two meters can read differently — and still be “accurate” by medical standards.
Test strips: Strips can vary in quality, storage, and expiration date, all of which can affect results.
User technique: Washing hands, using enough blood, and even the placement of the drop can make a difference.
Calibration: Some meters require regular calibration with control solutions.
Meter design: Some brands just run slightly higher or lower consistently.
Environmental conditions: Temperature and humidity may affect readings.
Meter age and battery: Older meters or low batteries can produce inconsistent readings.
Minor differences between meters are normal, but large or persistent discrepancies may indicate a problem that requires troubleshooting.
When you’re pregnant and managing GD, every number can feel high stakes. But here’s the good news: trends matter more than single numbers.
Providers are usually looking for patterns — whether your fasting is often elevated, or if certain meals consistently spike you. A few points of difference between meters won’t change your overall management plan, but staying consistent with one meter will give you the clearest picture.
Test side by side: Use both meters on the same drop of blood and compare results. This can help you see the range of difference.
Check for calibration: Some meters allow calibration (adjusting for accuracy). Check your manual or manufacturer’s instructions.
Check strips – Ensure they are stored correctly and not expired.
Bring your meter to your provider: Ask to test your blood sugar at the same time as their lab machine. This will give you a sense of how your meter runs compared to a clinical standard.
Stick with one meter: Even if it runs a little higher or lower, using the same one consistently will show trends — which is what matters most.
Watch the timing: Blood sugar can change quickly, so even testing a minute later on a second meter may show a different result.
If your numbers suddenly change by a lot and you’re further along in pregnancy (around 32–36 weeks, when insulin resistance naturally increases), it could be a real shift in your blood sugar rather than just the meter. Always bring big changes to your provider’s attention.
Stick to one meter for trend tracking, even if it reads slightly higher or lower.
Test under similar conditions (e.g., same time of day, before meals).
Keep a log of readings in an app or notebook for easy pattern spotting.
Ensure your meter has a full battery and is functioning properly.
While meter accuracy is key, lifestyle habits can also affect readings:
Pair carbohydrates with protein or healthy fats (“no naked carbs”).
Monitor portion sizes and balance your meals.
Include gentle activity after meals to help glucose uptake.
Stay hydrated consistently.
Glucose meters are incredibly helpful tools — but they’re not perfect. If you’ve switched and things suddenly look different, it doesn’t mean you’re doing anything wrong. Stick with one meter, pay attention to trends, and always reach out to your care team if you’re unsure.
Managing gestational diabetes is hard enough without second-guessing your tools. The goal is clarity and confidence — not perfection. 💛
1. Why do two meters give different readings for the same blood sample?
Differences can result from calibration, test strip type, user technique, meter design, and even environmental factors. Minor variations are normal, but large or consistent differences should be investigated.
2. Is it normal for a glucose meter to be slightly off?
Yes! Most meters are considered accurate if they’re within ±15% of lab reference values for readings above 100 mg/dL (or ±15 mg/dL for readings below 100 mg/dL). Consistently larger differences should be addressed.
3. How often should I calibrate my glucose meter?
Follow your manufacturer’s instructions; some meters require regular calibration with control solutions, while others are pre-calibrated. Regular calibration helps maintain accuracy.
4. Can diet, hydration, or other factors affect readings?
Yes. Dehydration, high fat meals, very low carb meals, or even recent exercise can slightly influence glucose readings. Try to measure under consistent conditions for more reliable trends.
5. Can expired or damaged test strips affect results?
Absolutely. Expired or improperly stored strips can give inaccurate readings. Always check expiration dates and store strips as recommended.
6. How can I check if my meter is accurate?
For some, you can use a control solution (provided by the manufacturer) to test your meter. Comparing readings with your provider’s meter or lab tests can also help ensure accuracy.
7. Should I track trends or individual readings?
Both are useful, but trends are more important. Even if a meter is slightly off, consistent use lets you see patterns and manage your blood sugar effectively.
8. What should I do if I notice unusual readings?
Re-test with a new strip, check your technique, and consider testing on another meter if possible. Contact your healthcare provider if unusual readings persist.
Get a Free 20-Day Shopping List
